X discussionReddit trades near 20–25x forward earnings after a post-earnings re-rating, and traders are arguing whether that discount is a buy or a trap. Bulls cite 60%+ revenue growth and fat margins against far richer peers; bears point to choppy Google search referrals, a decelerating Q3 sales guide, and relentless tape selling into late October earnings.
BullReddit is mispriced at roughly 25x forward earnings while growing about 60% with mid-20s operating margins. The same market pays far richer multiples for slower, unprofitable names, and eight straight quarters of 60%+ growth plus ~30x free-cash-flow leave the re-rate as the entry.
BearThe Google search-referral scare that crushed the last print still owns the tape, and selling keeps reversing every bounce. Licensing is a stale 5% of sales story with only about $30M of 2027 contracts signed, while Q3 guidance slows to the mid-40s percent and logged-in U.S. growth softens.
Posts
Bull evidence
@Mindset4Money_XRDDT at 25x forward earnings with 60% growth and 28% op margins is wildly cheaper than 190x peers growing 25% without profits.
@VJNCapitalRDDT looks cheap at 30x P/FCF while free cash flow grows 157% year over year.
@TheWiseICQuestions why buy APP over RDDT right now and frames Reddit as the cleaner opportunity versus a narrative-driven peer.
@Arkadi_XLast earnings selloff blamed Google search referrals, but management call comments on the issue got ignored.
Bear evidence
@SixSigmaCapitalRDDT printed a dragonfly doji then still fell about 3% after hours, showing buyers failed.
@inactive346677Shorts RDDT: licensing bull thesis is stale, logged-in fundamentals unchanged, and impression growth faces tough comps.